South Carolina judge denies Alex Murdaugh's request for new murder trial

A South Carolina judge on Monday denied Alex Murdaugh's request for a new murder trial.

Justice Jean Toal ruled Monday that she did not believe a new trial was needed for Murdaugh, who was convicted in the June 2021 murders of his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, on his family hunting estate.

Murdaugh was back in court Monday for a hearing on jury tampering allegations surrounding Colleton County Court Clerk Becky Hill, accusations which Murdaugh's defense team had argued warranted a new trial.

Toal said before her ruling Monday that while Hill was "attracted by the siren call of celebrity" and had made "fleeting and foolish comments," the jurors took their assignments seriously in convicting Murdaugh.

AELX MURDAUGH'S PUSH FOR NEW TRIAL COULD DEPEND ON ONE JUROR, ATTORNEY SAYS

Jurors who presided over Alex Murdaugh's murder trial testified about alleged jury tampering during Murdaugh's hearing for a new trial on Jan. 29, 2024. (Gavin McIntyre/The Post and Courier via AP, Pool)

Dick Harpootlian, Murdaugh's defense attorney, said Hill is "not credible" outside the courtroom after Toal's decision on Monday evening and said his team is "planning to appeal."

"We agree, and the court agrees, Becky Hill attempted to sway jurors. The only question is the law — not whether Hill influenced jurors," Harpootlian said.

Toal and Murdaugh's lawyers questioned Toal Monday about the tampering allegations. The jurors were also asked about her actions.

"As with all cases, the Attorney General’s Office and SLED’s only mission is to seek the truth and deliver justice, wherever the facts lead. It does not matter your name, position, or status, no one is above the law," South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson said in a statement following Toal's ruling. "We take very seriously the allegations in this situation."

Colleton County Court Clerk, Becky Hill crosses the street in Walterboro, South Carolina on Thursday, September 7, 2023. Hill is at the center of a motion for a retrial in the Alex Murdaugh double-murder case. (Larry Paci for Fox News Digital)

Wilson added that he "immediately requested an investigation" into Hill's conduct, "committed to discovering the truth regardless of what it might find."

"After that thorough investigation and a fair, public hearing, it is clear that Alex Murdaugh’s convictions for the murders of Maggie and Paul are based solely on the facts and evidence in the case," he continued. "He will spend the rest of his life behind bars because he was found guilty. It is time to move on from Alex Murdaugh."

One juror who presided over Murdaugh's double murder trial last year testified Monday that Hill's comments influenced her guilty verdict.

The juror, referred to as Juror Z, said Hill told jurors to watch Murdaugh "closely" and watch his "actions," adding that she reached a guilty verdict because of the clerk's comments.

Alex Murdaugh sits at the defense table during a judicial hearing at the Richland County Judicial Center in Columbia, S.C., Monday, Jan. 29, 2024.  (Tracy Glantz/The State via AP, Pool)

"To me…she made it seem like he was already guilty," Juror Z, the first to testify Monday, said when asked how the clerk inspired her verdict.

The disgraced lawyer's defense team argued that Hill allegedly pushed jurors to convict him in the June 2021 murders of his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, on his family hunting estate.

Juror Z also testified that other jurors also made her feel pressured to deliver a guilty verdict, as her affidavit stated.

ALEX MURDAUGH 'A SHELL OF A MAN' FOR FINANCIAL BETRAYAL, GLORIA SATTERFIELD SISTER TELLS INTERVIEWER

Of 12 total jurors who found Murdaugh guilty last spring, 11 said Hill did not influence their decisions. One said he heard the clerk make comments about watching Murdaugh's body language but said her words did not influence his verdict. 

Alex Murdaugh sits at the defense table during a judicial hearing at the Richland County Judicial Center in Columbia, S.C., Monday, Jan. 29, 2024.  (Tracy Glantz/The State via AP, Pool)

Following Juror Z's testimony on Monday morning, Toal announced on the record that jurors' cellphones had not been confiscated before proceedings began, and some of the jurors watched a live stream on their phones. The justice then called for a five-minute recess. 

"Murphy's law. What can go wrong will go wrong, at the worst possible time. And Murphy was an optimist."

— Justice Jean Toal

Toal asked all jurors from that point forward whether they watched the livestream and if it influenced their testimony on Monday. None of the jurors said their testimonies were impacted. 

The justice questioned the first of 12 jurors, referred to as Juror X, who presided over Murdaugh's trial on Friday about Hill's conduct because the juror had a scheduling conflict with Monday's proceedings.

ALEX MURDAUGH RETURNS TO COURT TO FIGHT FOR NEW MURDER TRIAL

Juror X said Hill's comments did not influence her verdict.

When Toal asked the juror about issues with private meetings that Hill apparently held and whether they had anything to do with the Murdaugh murder case, Juror X said the meetings were about a "different matter" and had "nothing to do with the case."

Prosecutor Creighton Waters, left, and defense attorney Dick Harpootlian stand during the Alex Murdaugh jury-tampering hearing at the Richland County Judicial Center, Monday, Jan. 29, 2024, in Columbia, S.C. (Andrew J. Whitaker/The Post And Courier via AP, Pool)

Toal made clear that Hill "is not on trial" heading of questioning Monday.

ALEX MURDAUGH GETS LEGAL WIN IN PUSH FOR NEW TRIAL

Murdaugh's lawyers, Harpootlian and Jim Griffin, alleged in their motion for a new trial that Hill advised jurors not to believe Murdaugh's testimony, pressured the panel to reach a "quick guilty verdict" and lied to the trial judge in a campaign to remove a panelist who was sympathetic to the defense.

"Ms. Hill did these things to secure for herself a book deal and media appearances that would not happen in the event of a mistrial," the filing says. "Ms. Hill betrayed her oath of office for money and fame."

Rebecca Hill arrives to the "Today" studio in New York City, March 6, 2023. She was the court clerk in the double-murder trial of Alex Murdaugh. (Jennifer Mitchell for Fox News Digital)

The South Carolina Law Enforcement Division opened two investigations into Hill's conduct during Murdaugh's murder trial, including a probe into allegations Hill used her position as clerk to benefit financially from sales of her book about the case, which she later admitted included plagiarized writing, and another probe into the jury tampering allegations.

Murdaugh, 55, was sentenced in March to two life terms for the murders.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

The disgraced South Carolina lawyer was also sentenced to 27 years in November for his financial crimes. He agreed to plead guilty to 22 counts — including breach of trust, money laundering, forgery and tax evasion — out of about 100 counts totaling as much as $10 million in exchange for the 27-year prison sentence.

Murdaugh previously pleaded guilty to 22 counts of financial fraud and money laundering in federal court.

Fox News' Chelsea Torres and Rebecca Rosenberg contributed to this report.