Children once held hostage still working through trauma: 'Are they coming for us again?'

Dr. Efrat Bron-Harlev, CEO of Schneider Children’s Medical Center of Israel, recently addressed the United Nations about the plight of the children who were kidnapped from Israel by Hamas terrorists on Oct. 7, 2023. 

She said that 38 of the 253 people who were abducted that day were children. The youngest was Kfir Bibas, just eight months old at the time. 

The child is still in captivity, along with his parents, Yarden and Shiri Bibas, and his brother, Ariel, who turned five last month.

THRIVING WITH ANXIETY: EXPERT TIPS ON EMBRACING THE MENTAL HEALTH CONDITION 

Bron-Harlev, a pediatrician, said children released after 50 days in captivity are still, to this day, waking up terrified in the middle of the night.

"They were not allowed to cry, not allowed to laugh, not even allowed to stand up."

She said the children appeared "like shadows of children. No impressions on their faces. They were not happy. They were not crying. They were mostly very, very silent."

Thirty-eight of the 253 people abducted by Hamas on Oct. 7, 2023 were children — including Kfir Bibas, just eight months old at the time (shown above). The child is still in captivity, along with his parents, Yarden and Shiri Bibas, and his brother, Ariel, who turned five last month. (Bethany Mandel)

Dr. Hagai Levine, chair of the Israeli Association of Public Health and head physician of the Hostages and Missing Families Forum, also reported seeing children being afraid to speak. 

"In captivity, they were told, ‘If you speak, you will be killed’ — that's very, very traumatizing," he told Fox News Digital.

In addition to psychological trauma, the hostages were also in extreme physical danger. 

Levine, who is also an epidemiologist, said the risks to the hostages’ lives ranged from the threat of "being murdered to lack of food to lack of oxygen, lack of water (and) infectious diseases."

‘Every child has a right to health’ 

Referencing the recent polio outbreak in Gaza, Levine noted that he sent a letter to UNICEF and the World Health Organization reminding the organizations "that every child has a right to health — and this includes Kfir and Ariel Bibas." 

Levine said he was on a bus this summer with children who were formerly hostages as well as children who are relatives of hostages. 

"They have the unique ability to cope."

The young ones attended a U.S. summer camp in July, he said. 

"I saw songs and jokes," he said, recalling his observations. "I’m not saying they were happy, but they have the unique ability to cope."

The doctor said he knows these children have had to grow up quickly — but the "plasticity of the brain" helps children rehabilitate, he said. 

Dr. Hagai Levine, chair of the Israeli Association of Public Health, is shown speaking at a press conference near the headquarters of the families of the abductees in Tel Aviv on Nov. 15, 2023.   (Hadar Badar)

He said he has encouraged them to play and dance. 

However, "there is always a shadow" holding them back, he said — given that at this moment, there are still other hostages held captive. 

Helping them regain trust

Levine said these children grew up in a tight-knit community of a kibbutz — and seeing hostage posters everywhere of their neighbors is very real to them. 

"It’s really difficult for them to really recover," he said.

SEVERE BURNS REPORTED IN CHILDREN MAKING TIKTOK-FRIENDLY GLASS FRUIT IN MICROWAVE

It is a long process to get these children to be able to trust again, Levine said, and they need someone who is a constant in their lives, especially if their parents were murdered. 

He said physical, psychological and educational rehabilitation, such as speech therapy and equine therapy, can help them to regain trust and feel in control.

They "have been in this horrible nightmare" for nearly a year. 

He also noted that relatives of the hostages are experiencing survivor guilt, severe depression, anxiety, insomnia and physical symptoms such as tremors. 

They are traumatized because they don’t know what happened to their loved ones, and they "have been in this horrible nightmare" for nearly a year at this point, he said.

‘Could have been me’ 

Roxanne Saar, the aunt of released hostage Gali Tarshansky, age 13, told Fox News Digital, "I feel like it could have been me." 

Saar had been staying at her father-in-law’s home at Kibbutz Be’eri on Oct. 6, 2023, when she decided to return home that night. 

LACK OF SLEEP POSES CONCERNING RISK FOR KIDS, STUDY FINDS

The next day, 101 civilians at Be’eri were killed by Hamas terrorists and 32 people were kidnapped, according to JNS (Jewish News Syndicate). 

Gali Tarshansky's brother, Lior, 15, and her uncle, Noy Shosh, 36, were among the murdered victims. 

Adults from left, above: Roxanne Saar, Gonen Saar (Aroussi), Yehuda Aroussi, Gali Tarshansky, Noy Shosh, Mahol Shosh, Lliya Tarshansky, Reuma Aroussi Tarshansky and Lior Tarshansky. (Family of Gali Tarshansky)

Saar said that the first question the young teenager asked when she was released from captivity after 54 days was, "Where is Lior?"

It was not until after she returned to Israel that she discovered her brother and uncle had been killed, along with her dog, Mocha, as well as friends she grew up with from her kibbutz.

She was held hostage in homes in Gaza with Nova festival survivors and a couple from Kibbutz Be’eri. The husband, Ohad Ben Ami, is still a hostage, Saar said.

"There was no showering, there was no water."

Saar said that in Gaza, "there was not enough food, there was not enough medicine, there was no showering, there was no water … There was psychological terror." 

ISRAELI SOLDIER GRAVELY INJURED IN OCT. 7 TERROR ATTACK FINDS NEW FAITH, OFFERS HOPE TO OTHERS

She said the young woman's captors, some of whom were armed, told her, "Israel does not exist. Your family doesn't want you anymore.’"

Saar added, "I'm not sure if we know everything … I don't have any expectations from terrorists who are capable of kidnapping a 13-year-old girl."

It is crucial, she said, for the remaining hostages to be freed in order for the released hostages to heal.

Gali Tarshansky, above, in July 2023, with her brother Lior Tarshansky. "I don't think there is anyone in the world who can understand the potential future impact of what happened," the siblings' aunt told Fox News Digital, referencing Oct. 7, 2023 and its aftermath. "Everybody wants to help, but how can someone help with something that we never knew before?" (Family of Gali Tarshansky)

Saar said Gali Tarshansky is living in a different area of Israel today, attending a new school. She is in therapy. 

Said Saar, "I don't think there is anyone in the world who can understand the potential future impact of what happened … Everybody wants to help, but how can someone help with something that we never knew before?"

‘Takes a long time’

Professor Merev Roth, PhD, an analyst who works with the Hostages and Missing Families Forum, told Fox News Digital that therapists who are treating released hostages are in uncharted territory. 

"Will he come back when I'm really old?"

"All of this is new," she said. "There is not one case in history that so many kids and families were kidnapped from their houses for such a long time and in such a brutal massacre."

Roth is one of the founders of First Line Med (FLM), an organization that offers pro bono treatment to victims of Oct. 7. 

SURVIVOR OF HAMAS TERROR ATTACK ON ISRAEL RECOUNTS PAIN, GRIEF OF LOSING ‘ANGEL’ BOYFRIEND ON OCT. 7 

She supervises child therapists and treats adult family members of child hostages who were released after 50 or 54 days in captivity.

Roth said she had to treat some of the families in their homes or hotels initially, because they were afraid to go outside. 

Tarshansky, left, with her half-sister Eden Tarshansky — who suffered the loss of her mother, Silvia Ohayon, who was killed in Kibbutz Be’eri.  (Family of Gali Tarshansky)

She recalled seeing how frightened a three-and-a-half-year old toddler was when the child heard a gardener working outside. 

"I remember the girl running into her mother's body, and her mother immediately took her in her arms. The girl didn't say a word. She was white, she was shaking, she didn't even cry," Roth said.

Another time, when the little girl heard noises outside, Roth said the girl asked, "Are they coming for us again?"

Roth said another child released from captivity is unable to get through a full day of school in kindergarten. 

Merev Roth, an analyst who works with the Hostages and Missing Families Forum, told Fox News Digital she recalled seeing how frightened a three-and-a-half-year old toddler was when she heard a gardener working outside.  (Yehoshua Yosef)

Her father is still a hostage, and Roth said she knows he is in danger and asks her mother, "Is Father dead? Will he come back when I'm really old?"

Roth said the children who were separated from their parents in captivity, or witnessed family members being murdered or wounded, "shattered in the most extreme, brutal way" a child’s sense of safety and trust in the world. 

"They become easily frustrated, angry and disassociated."

Some children had captors who were abusive and threatening; other hostages experienced Stockholm Syndrome, where they identified with their captor, Roth said. 

JEWISH COOKING ‘GODMOTHER’ RECREATES VIVID FAMILY MEMORIES AND ‘SENSE OF BELONGING’ THROUGH FOOD

Antisemitism spreading across the globe is "a big blow," said Roth. "It added to the feelings that the world went crazy, that everything is distorted."

She said these children are suffering from "trauma syndrome symptoms," such as anxiety, depression, sleeping disorders and social withdrawal. 

They become easily frustrated, angry and disassociated, which means "you are disconnected from your emotional response … You become confused. You cannot concentrate and you don't react emotionally in your full scope. You are a bit numb," she said.

The released children (not pictured) are suffering from "trauma syndrome symptoms," such as anxiety, depression, sleeping disorders and social withdrawal, one expert said. (iStock)

Dissociation can also be self-protective, Roth noted.

"It takes a long time until they come back into their senses, which is a good thing, because their psyche protects them from feeling all that they would feel if they were connected, and it would be overwhelming for them."

For more Health articles, visit www.foxnews.com/health

The therapist said these children are struggling to feel normal. 

"They do find any channel they can to be smiling and friendly and cooperative. They're really trying … They are amazing in their coping, but they are injured."

Play therapy, she said, enables children to reenact real experiences through imaginary scenarios, and gives therapists insight into their inner thoughts. 

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR HEALTH NEWSLETTER

"You can see the split of the world into total good and total bad creatures fighting each other … I see complete evil, revenge, abuse and angels," she said. 

"You can also see the other side … life saviors that came from nowhere to save them." 

A seven-year-old boy said he was the "cat hero," helping the cats he drew to fall asleep and feel less afraid.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP   

He also wrote a touching story with his therapist about a family of kittens who had been kidnapped and were found. Roth said that the child told his therapist, "Now we can finish therapy, because the kitties are back home."

Said Roth, "I'm always overwhelmed by the beauty and the strength and the resilience."