'Mr. Grinchmas showed up to steal a Christmas tree': Police
Vehicle pulls up, person exits before cutting ropes to take tree from roof of SUV in California. Credit: Anonymous via Storyful
From the top of the corporate mountain, Dr. Seuss Enterprises taps its fingers against a snow-covered rock like the scene in "The Grinch" cartoon when the Grinch is repulsed at the bustling, happy town of Whoville.
Instead of the green meanie plotting how to stop Christmas, the real-life corporation issues cease and desist letters and can take legal action against anyone using the Grinch's image and likeness to make money.
One particular clash in 2019 went viral, and as trademark lawyer John Rizvi said in a blog post, Jacob Marley's ghost returns every holiday season with warnings to photographers.
"Friendly reminder that doing Grinch photo sessions FOR A PROFIT is federal trademark infringement, and Dr. Seuss Int. literally hires out a team this time of year to reverse image search and sue photogs for profit," Tennessee-based photographer Brittany Kay wrote in a Facebook warning.
HOLIDAY SHOPPING: 5 TIPS TO STAY SAFE FROM SELF-DEFENSE INSTRUCTOR
Taylor Momsen and Jim Carrey in the 2000 film "How The Grinch Stole Christmas." (Universal/Entertainment Pictures/Alamy Pictures)
"Unless you got $120,000 for a license, that’s not a lawsuit you will win!"
Which prompts the question that Rizvi, aka The Patent Professor, asked in his blog post: "Has Dr. Seuss lost the plot and become the very character he lampooned, or are photographers and crafters really the ones who are trying to steal Christmas here?"
The Grinch is a registered trademark and covered under copyright law until Jan. 1, 2062, at the very earliest, Rizvi said.
HOLIDAY SHOPPERS ‘NEED TO KEEP HEAD ON SWIVEL’ AS EXPERT PREDICTS HOSTILE SEASON
Copyright laws are "intended to protect original creations," and trademark law "prevents mark dilution and brand confusion," according to The Patent Professor.
And from a legal standpoint, the trademark and copyright holder "is required to defend their intellectual property against infringement and unauthorized use," Rizvi said.
"Dr. Seuss Enterprises isn't the bad guy."
That means "using all legal mechanisms at their disposal," he wrote. "If you don't use these protections, you could easily lose them, and the right to your IP altogther."
While there's the outside appearance of Dr. Seuss Enterprises being grinchy to protect the Grinch, it's actually its obligation to crack down on unauthorized use, Rizvi said.
"While it’s tempting for laypeople to paint them as the antagonists here, Dr. Seuss Enterprises isn’t the bad guy," the Florida-based lawyer said. "Nor, for that matter, is Dr. Seuss himself, who died in 1991."
SUSPECT CHARGED WITH MURDERING SECURITY GUARD INSIDE PHILADELPHIA MACY'S AFTER DEADLY STABBING
In this photo provided by the Florida Keys News Bureau, Monroe County Sheriff's Office Col. Lou Caputo, right, dressed as the Grinch, leans on the shoulder of Deputy Andrew Leird, left, as he uses a laser speed detector to check speeds of motorists traveling through a school zone on the Florida Keys Overseas Highway Dec. 13, 2022, in Marathon, Fla. (Andy Newman/Florida Keys News Bureau via AP)
This controversy boiled over in 2019, when Arkansas photographer Kim Durham snapped pictures of a teenager dressed as the Grinch surrounded by children as they recreated the night the green meanie stole Christmas.
The photos went viral, and the story was picked up by major national news outlets.
Durham's Christmas present from Dr. Seuss Enterprises was a cease and desist letter that demanded all the digital and physical copies of the photos be destroyed, that she refrain from posting Grinch-themed pictures in the future and that she cancel all scheduled Grinch-themed photo shoots, Rizvi said.
Durham ultimately complied, and the corporation's heart grew three sizes and settled the issue without taking money.
FStoppers, a photography-based news outlet, issued a warning last week about this issue.
Dr. Seuss' "The Grinch" musical. (David Cotter/NBC)
The Dec. 10 story included several of Rizvi's points while emphasizing how Dr. Seuss Enterprises' "actively protects its intellectual property rights, especially during the holiday season."
"While holiday-themed photoshoots are a delightful part of the season, photographers must be cautious about using copyrighted characters like The Grinch for profit," the FStoppers story said.
"It is advisable to either obtain the necessary licenses or avoid using such themes in commercial sessions to prevent legal complications and safeguard your business."
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Fox News Digital reached out to Dr. Seuss Enterprises with questions, but it didn't immediately respond.
Rizvi summed up the easiest "workaround": "Just get the license!"
True Crime
The hottest stories ripped from the headlines, from crime to courts, legal and scandal.
By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.
