Media top headlines May 3
NPR devoting 8 full minutes for WaPo's Kessler to defend Tim Scott's family fact check and more round out today's top media headlines.
NPR allowed the Washington Post's "fact-checker" Glenn Kessler eight minutes to defend his widely criticized piece that questioned Sen. Tim Scott's, R-S.C., story about how his family made their way "from cotton to Congress."
Kessler explained that Scott's origin story, like those of many politicians, sounded a little too "tidy," and so he decided it would make an "interesting" fact check.
Kessler noted in his piece that Scott's humble beginnings were more "complex" than the senator let on, particularly because Scott’s great-great-grandfather owned 900 acres in South Carolina, and Scott’s grandfather, Artis Ware, worked on that farm. Social media united in ripping Kessler for the controversial piece, calling it "cringe," "embarrassing" and "racist." Kessler said "it was not a very good day for me to see that spread with such vehement across the internet."
MSNBC'S TIFFANY CROSS BLASTS TIM SCOTT AS 'TOKEN' AND 'CLOWN'
According to Kessler, his critics "twisted" his argument to make it sound more sinister. He noted defensively that he relied on property records to write his piece and he sticks by his conclusion that the narrative Sen. Scott has been telling America is misleading.
"The article acknowledges that Sen. Scott may not have known his full family history and that the census records regarding the lives of Black Americans can be inconsistent," Kessler told NPR. "But some critics have twisted that appropriate caution to suggest that all of the documentation in the article is suspect. I also obtained property and other records that expanded on information in the census, and those records are not in dispute. And those property records show how much land his great-grandfather purchased. And he appears to have been one of the biggest landowners, white or Black, in Aiken County at the time."
NPR host Michel Martin appeared to give Kessler the benefit of the doubt when she asked him why his take would be considered a bad thing, as it shows how "successful" Scott's ancestors were.
"So - but why would a story about your ancestors being successful, especially at a time when the odds were so stacked against them, be viewed as a negative thing? I mean, you point that out in your piece. You point out that this was a remarkable achievement," Martin wondered.
Kessler agreed and said it only supports his argument that Sen. Scott is stretching the truth when he says he rose from "virtually nothing to the heights of the Senate." The writer mused that the "inconsistencies" in Scott's story probably make him "uncomfortable." He added only briefly that Scott's ancestors couldn't have been all that privileged because they were living in the era of the Jim Crow South.
Sen. Scott singled out Kessler and the Washington Post in his Republican rebuttal to President Biden's first address to a joint session of Congress last Wednesday.
CLICK HERE FOR THE FOX NEWS APP
"Just last week, a national newspaper suggested that my family's poverty was actually privilege because a relative owned land generations before my time," Scott said, adding that in the aftermath of the controversy he had again been maligned as an "Uncle Tim" by progressives and liberals.
Sen. Scott reasoned that while he's experienced racism in his lifetime, he believes that America is not a racist nation, which was a radical statement to many media pundits.
Kessler said he was surprised by Scott's reaction because he "gave Scott and his staff every opportunity to respond" to his research.
Fox News First
Get all the stories you need-to-know from the most powerful name in news delivered first thing every morning to your inbox.
By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.