American presidents once revered the Supreme Court: Here's what we can learn from William Howard Taft

EXCLUSIVE: The White House and the Supreme Court have a complicated relationship these days. 

When President Biden took office, he launched a commission on reorganizing the court, responding to calls for structural reforms — and the court has pushed back on many of his most far-reaching policies. 

At the same time, former President Trump, who nominated three people to the Supreme Court, faces multiple legal matters that may end up before the justices. 

JARED COHEN, BESTSELLING AUTHOR, TO RELEASE ‘LIFE AFTER POWER,’ NEW BOOK ON SEVEN FORMER PRESIDENTS

Yet there was a time when presidents revered the court, and they believed that keeping the bench beyond politics was necessary not only for the separation of powers, but America’s way of life. No president embodied this philosophy more than William Howard Taft. 

Of course, it helped that Taft hadn’t wanted to be president in the first place. 

He wanted to be the chief justice. 

Jared Cohen (left) devotes a full chapter of his new book, "Life After Power" (Feb. 2024, Simon & Schuster), to William Howard Taft (right), who led the Supreme Court as chief justice for nearly 10 years after his time as president of the United States. "He was a judge at heart, and he acted like it, even as president," writes Cohen in this exclusive excerpt from his book.  (Fox News Digital; Library of Congress/Corbis/VCG via Getty Images)

Taft’s father, Alphonso, was America’s attorney general, and he instilled in his son the belief that "to be chief justice of the United States is more than to be president." 

After graduating from Yale, William Howard Taft became the youngest judge in Ohio, at age 29. 

At 32, he was solicitor general of the United States. 

PRESIDENTIAL COMEBACKS ARE NOT ALL THEY'RE CRACKED UP TO BE, AS GROVER CLEVELAND'S STORY SHOWS

He argued 18 cases before the court, winning 15 of them. 

The Supreme Court, not the White House, looked like it was next.

The two most important people in his life had other ideas: his wife, Nellie Taft, and Theodore Roosevelt.

Taft wasn’t a politician, and he’d never run for office before he was president. 

Nellie Taft didn’t want to be a judge’s wife; she wanted to be first lady (and, in a different age, might have run for president herself). 

Theodore Roosevelt offered Taft a spot on the bench on three occasions, but the timing was never right — and Roosevelt and Nellie conspired to get Taft into the White House instead. 

ON THIS DAY IN HISTORY, APRIL 14, 1910, PRESIDENT TAFT THROWS OUT FIRST PITCH AT MLB GAME

With the plans coming into place, over dinner at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue one night, Roosevelt teased his famously rotund guest, "I see a man weighing 350 pounds. There is something hanging over his head… At one time it looks like the presidency, then again it looks like the chief justiceship." 

"Make it the chief justiceship," pleaded Mr. Taft. 

William Howard Taft, who served as both president of the United States and chief justice of the Supreme Court (front, third from left), poses with Federal Appeals judges outside the U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C., on Sept. 27, 1923. He was named chief justice of SCOTUS in 1921.  (Library of Congress)

"Make it the presidency," replied Mrs. Taft. 

Mrs. Taft got her way in 1908. 

Taft wasn’t a politician, and he’d never run for office before he was president. 

He’d been appointed to every government job he’d ever had. But he was a judge at heart, and he acted like it — even as president.

AFTER THEY LEAVE THE WHITE HOUSE, WHAT SHOULD AMERICA DO WITH OUR EX-PRESIDENTS?

Whereas Roosevelt used the bully pulpit to push Congress in one direction or another, proposing and advocating policies on everything from conservation, to antitrust, to foreign policy, Taft did not. He believed in a constitutionally limited role for his office, and that all legislative power belonged with Congress, not the president. 

That constitutionalist philosophy determined how he engaged in policy debates. When Congress went back and forth about tariffs, Taft didn’t call members telling them how to vote. 

Instead, he issued a short, 340-word statement that didn’t take a position and just emphasized the importance of the matter: "The less time given to other subjects of legislation in this session," he advised, "the better for the country." 

As constitutional scholar Jeffrey Rosen notes, Taft was "the only president to approach the office in constitutional terms above all." 

The U.S. Supreme Court is seen in this file image on Nov. 15, 2023, in Washington, D.C. Taft became the 10th chief justice of the United States in 1921. By that point, after more than six decades of waiting for the position, Taft told his new colleagues, "I don’t remember that I was ever president."  (AP Photo/Mariam Zuhaib/File)

Not everyone in the Republican Party appreciated that approach. 

Contemporaries once joked that T.A.F.T. stood for "take advice from Theodore" — but TR grew angry at his successor’s policies and personnel choices. 

When a frustrated Roosevelt ran as a third-party Bull Moose candidate against Taft in 1912, though, he handed the presidency to Woodrow Wilson, a man very unlike Taft who believed the Constitution was out of step with the times. 

CRISIS ON COLLEGE CAMPUSES: WHAT UNIVERSITY PRESIDENTS CAN LEARN FROM THE FOUNDING FATHERS

Wilson said the document "was founded on the law of gravitation… The trouble with the theory is that government is not a machine, but a living thing. No living thing can have its organs offset against each other, as checks, and live."

Before Wilson, in his own four years as president, Taft had made his mark on the Supreme Court. 

Taft was behind the effort to get the Supreme Court its own building. Until then, its chambers were in the basement of the U.S. Capitol. 

He nominated six justices, more than any other president in a single term, before or since. But he always had in the back of his mind that he’d one day be heading to the bench, and he once jokingly told his nominees, "Damn you, if any of you die, I’ll disown you!"   

He did join them in 1921, when Republican Warren G. Harding made Taft the 10th chief justice of the United States. By that point, after more than six decades of waiting, Taft told his new colleagues, "I don’t remember that I was ever president." 

1909: William Howard Taft (1857-1930) served as 27th president of the United States. He later served as chief justice of the Supreme Court and is the only president to have led two branches of the federal government.  (Hulton Archive/Getty Images)

For nearly 10 years, Taft led the Article III branch, writing majority opinions and dissents on issues of the day, including Prohibition, surveillance, labor and the limits of presidential power. 

He changed how the Supreme Court chooses its case docket, and he was behind the effort to get the Supreme Court its own building (until then, its chambers were in the basement of the U.S. Capitol, but Taft believed that the separation of powers required separate facilities).

Near the end of his life, after Taft retired from the bench, Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes visited. 

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR LIFESTYLE NEWSLETTER

He told his old boss, "We call you Chief Justice still, for we cannot give up the title by which we have known you all these later years and which you have made so dear to us." 

The president, and even Congress, can choose to make the court about politics — or they can choose to direct it toward the Constitution. 

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

Taft chose the latter. 

In so doing, he reminded the justices, and the country, why the courts matter — and the importance of their role in our constitutional system of government.

Excerpted from "Life After Power: Seven Presidents and Their Search for Purpose Beyond the White House," © copyright Jared Cohen (Simon & Schuster, Feb. 2024), by special arrangement. All rights reserved. 

Stay tuned for more excerpts from "Life After Power" at Fox News Digital. 

For more Lifestyle articles, visit www.foxnews.com/lifestyle.