Prior COVID infection provides just as much protection as vaccines, new study finds

close

Video

Brianne Dressen: The COVID vaccines are held to a totally different standard

Brianne Dressen reveals her permanent disability after participating in a 2020 AstraZeneca clinical trial.

A new study found that a previous COVID-19 infection offers at least the same level of protection as two doses of high-quality mRNA vaccines, such as Moderna and Pfizer-BioNTech.

Additionally, people who are infected with the virus may be protected from reinfection for 40 weeks or longer, the study found.

It was published in The Lancet on Feb. 16.

ARKANSAS MOM SAYS SCHOOL MASK MANDATES LED TO ‘CRUELTY AND DISCRIMINATION’ AGAINST HER DAUGHTER

Protection from reinfection was highest for the ancestral (original) strain of COVID-19 and the alpha, beta and delta variants, remaining at more than 78% after 40 weeks. 

Protection was lower for the omicron BA.1 variant, which dropped to 36.1% in that same time frame.

People who are infected with the COVID-19 virus may be protected from reinfection for 40 weeks or longer, a new study found. (Fox New Digital)

When it comes to severe disease (hospitalization or death), protection was high across all variants, averaging 78% or higher for ancestral, alpha, beta, delta and omicron BA.1 at 40 weeks after infection.

The level of protection declined over time for all variants, but it dipped fastest for the omicron BA.1 variant.

The study, titled "Past SARS-CoV-2 infection protection against re-infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis," was led by a group of researchers that make up the COVID-19 Forecasting Team.

Previous COVID-19 infection offers at least the same level of protection as two doses of high-quality mRNA vaccines.

Dr. Marc Siegel, professor of medicine at NYU Langone Medical Center in New York City and a Fox News medical contributor, told Fox News Digital that immunity from prior infection (known as natural immunity) and immunity from vaccines both provide significant protection against severe illness and some protection (for at least a few months) against getting the virus again.

"This is the reason that I don't generally recommend the vaccine booster for at least a few months following infection," he said.

YEARLY COVID VACCINE AS PROPOSED BY FDA? 'CART BEFORE THE HORSE,' SAYS DOCTOR

Dr. Siegel said the strongest immunity is a combination of both, known as hybrid immunity — but he would never recommend that anyone get infected deliberately. 

Dr. Marc Siegel said he doesn't generally recommend the vaccine booster for at least a few months following infection. (AP Photo/Matt Rourke, File)

"It’s too unpredictable in terms of disease outcome and the risk of long COVID," he said.

The new study's findings could call into question vaccine requirement policies.

WOMEN MORE LIKELY TO SUFFER FROM ‘LONG COVID,’ BUT HEALTHY HABITS CAN LOWER THE RISK

"This finding also has important implications for the design of policies that restrict access to travel or venues or require vaccination for workers," the study authors wrote. 

"It supports the idea that those with a documented infection should be treated similarly to those who have been fully vaccinated with high-quality vaccines."

A new study found that previous COVID-19 infection offers at least the same level of protection as two doses of high-quality mRNA vaccines. (Mario Tama/Getty Images)

Researchers analyzed a total of 65 studies across 19 countries. 

The studies compared people who had previously recovered from COVID-19 to those who had not been infected, through Sept. 31, 2022. 

When evaluating the infected cases, researchers considered the severity of symptoms, the variant of the virus and how long it had been since people tested positive.

The authors noted in the findings that this is the first study to "comprehensively assess natural immunity protection against COVID-19 reinfection by variant (primary infection and reinfection) and to evaluate waning immunity with time since primary infection."

As of Feb. 15, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported an average of 259,339 new COVID cases per week.

The study did have some limitations. 

There was a low number of studies to evaluate, for example, and not much data was available beyond the 40-week mark. 

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR HEALTH NEWSLETTER

Additionally, studies relied on different methods to determine previous infection status, including testing for antibodies and looking at prior COVID-19 test results.

As of Feb. 15, only 16% of the U.S. population has received the updated booster dose of COVID-19 vaccines, while 69% have completed a primary series of vaccines. (iStock)

As of Feb. 15, the CDC reported an average of 259,339 new COVID cases per week. 

The peak was 5.6 million cases per week in January 2022.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

Only 16% of the U.S. population has received the updated booster dose for COVID-19 vaccines.

Meanwhile, 69% of the population has completed a primary series of vaccines.