Criminal defense lawyer discusses how the Karen Read murder trial could impact another homicide case
The same Massachusetts district attorney is prosecuting Karen Read and Brian Walshe, but disturbing details have come to light.
A state trooper's "unprofessional" texts read out loud in court during the spectacle of Karen Read's murder trial opened Pandora's box.
And "there's no way to undo this," law expert Shira Diner told Fox News Digital about restoring credibility and trust.
Jurors shook their heads last week as Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor, the lead investigator in the case, read his own texts that included calling Read a "wack job," a "babe … with no a--" and a "c---;" wishing she would kill herself; and joking about looking for nudes on her phone.
The optics are ugly, but the ramifications could be worse. Proctor, who works out of the Norfolk District Attorney's Office, also played a prominent role in the homicide case against Brian Walshe.
Karen Read waits as her legal team meets at the side bar during her trial in Norfolk Superior Court, Friday, June 14, 2024, in Dedham, Mass. Read, 44, is accused of running into her Boston police officer boyfriend with her SUV in the middle of a nor'easter and leaving him for dead after a night of heavy drinking. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa, Pool)
Walshe is accused of killing his wife, Ana, during an early-morning fight on New Year's Day 2023, and disposing of her body, which still hasn't been found.
The Norfolk District Attorney's Office filed criminal charges against Walshe, and Proctor is the designated case officer.
Proctor said during his testimony that the texts were "unprofessional and regrettable," as he was being pummeled by the defense's cross-examination, but stood by the integrity of the investigation.
SUSPECTED KILLER THREW AWAY HACKSAW WITH POTENTIAL KEY PIECE OF EVIDENCE
"It's hard for me to see how this doesn't impact this (Brian Walshe's case) and the credibility of the DA's office," Diner said.
The Norfolk District Attorney's Office declined to comment on Read's trial or potential aftermath, and the Massachusetts State Police didn't respond to Fox News Digital's requests for comment.
Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor testifies during Karen Read's trial, Wednesday, June 12, 2024, in Norfolk Superior Court in Dedham, Mass. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger via AP, Pool)
Brian Walshe, accused of killing wife Ana, who disappeared on New Year's Day 2023, enters the courtroom for his arraignment, Thursday, April 27, 2023, in Dedham, Mass. Walshe has been charged with first-degree murder as well as misleading a police investigation/obstruction of justice and improper conveyance of a human body. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger via AP, Pool)
Diner is a lecturer and clinical instructor at Boston University School of Law and the president of the Massachusetts Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. She's not involved in Read's or Walshe's cases.
"In some ways, this is completely unchartered," Diner said because of how detailed the texts are and how many eyes are on this particular trial.
WATCH: DASHCAM FROM THE NIGHT JOHN O'KEEFE WAS FOUND DEAD
Read allegedly ran over her boyfriend – Boston police officer John O'Keefe – during a booze-fueled fight in January 2022 and left him to die on the front lawn during a blizzard, according to prosecutors.
She denied the allegations and alleged she was set up by the Albert family, an influential clan that owns the Canton, Massachusetts, home where O'Keefe's body was found.
Brian and Ana Walshe on their wedding day in Emmanuel Episcopal church on Newbury St., Boston, Massachusetts on Monday, Dec. 21, 2015. (Obtained by Fox News Digital)
Karen Read is accused of killing her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O'Keefe, with her car in January 2022. She pleaded not guilty. (John Tlumacki/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
Read's defense team claimed the Albert family orchestrated an elaborate cover-up using friends in law enforcement agencies and the prosecutor's office.
The murder-or-conspiracy trial fit for a TV drama became even more salacious when the Boston suburb spiraled into split allegiances. #FreeKaren billboards cropped up, and protesters and supporters clashed.
A Read supporter and controversial blogger with a loyal following – Aidan "Turtleboy" Kearney – was arrested and hit with witness intimidation charges shortly before the trial began.
He pleaded not guilty, but the arrest riled up the pro-Read base and Kearney's readers, who call themselves "Turtleriders," and poured gasoline on the fire.
"If this was a trial where no one was paying attention, the cross-examination (of Proctor) would have come and gone, and maybe a few defense lawyers would have been paying attention, but that's pretty much it," Diner said. "But now, there's no way to undo this."
WHAT'S IN A SMILE? WHY IS BRIAN WALSHE SMIRKING IN CUFFS? CRIMINAL PSYCHIATRIST ANSWERS
Hundreds of Karen Read supporters gather in front of Norfolk County Superior Court before her appearance. (Matt Stone/MediaNews Group/Boston Herald via Getty Images)
Massachusetts blogger Aidan "Turtleboy" Kearney was charged with witness intimidation for allegedly threatening witnesses in a murder case in Massachusetts. (Aidan Kearney(@DoctorTurleboy)/X)
Walshe's lawyer, Larry Tipton, already took notice, and told local news outlets, like NBC 10 Boston, that he plans on filing new motions that name Proctor, as well as any other investigators implicated in Read's trial.
He said he hasn't concluded if Proctor tainted the investigation against his client, NBC 10 Boston reported.
Brian Walshe seen at Quincy District Court in connection to the disappearance of his wife, Ana Walshe. (WBZ)
Tipton didn't return Fox News Digital's calls for comment, and a new motion hasn't been filed yet. Walshe's next pre-trial hearing is scheduled for Friday.
As an outside legal expert, Diner said Proctor's testimony potentially sank the Commonwealth's case, and will likely impact Walshe's trial and any other case where this DA's office and Proctor are involved.
Ana Walshe pictured in front of a Ritz-Carlton hotel sign in August 2022. (Ana Walshe/Instagram)
Ana Walshe holds her three children in an October 2022 Instagram post. (Ana Walshe/Instagram)
Because of credibility concerns, defense attorneys in future cases involving Proctor could move to have him impeached, Diner said.
"It's an extreme in what we're dealing with," she said. "There are police officers who are not credible, whose bias comes up all the time. That's in more cases than not.
"But the degree to which the defense lawyer has this information about actual statements this officer made is pretty rare … And what makes this even more unique is that it's so public."
ANA WALSHE SAID HUSBAND WAS 'TAUGHT TO LIE' AND 'TOLD HE WAS A LOSER' AS A CHILD: COURT DOCS
Walshe's lawyer didn't tip his hand about what motions he would file.
Diner can only speculate on what Tipton's next move could be (which she discussed in detail in the interview below).
WATCH: DINER LAYS OUT POTENTIAL LEGAL STRATEGIES IN MURDER CASE AGAINST WALSHE
There's a bigger issue than the context of the texts
What's vital to know, according to Diner, is how the defense got their hands on Proctor's texts.
Did prosecutors voluntarily turn them over during discovery, or did Read's lawyers get them elsewhere? That will determine if the credibility of the prosecutor's office is tarnished, she said.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
"As a criminal defense lawyer, I would have a lot more respect for the DA's office if they turned it over, if they were forthcoming," Diner said.
"But if it turns out (Read's) defense lawyer got that information … some other way, and it wasn't turned over, that's a strike against the DA's office in terms of their credibility."
Fox News Digital's Bonny Chu contributed to this report.
True Crime
The hottest stories ripped from the headlines, from crime to courts, legal and scandal.
By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.
