Idaho judge in Bryan Kohberger case slams defense for possibly 'inculpatory' questionnaires
Idaho Judge John Judge on Thursday condemned the defense in the Bryan Kohberger murder case for distributing questionnaires that could be 'inculpatory' to Latah County residents.
Lawyers for the Washington State University criminology Ph.D. student accused of massacring four University of Idaho undergrads in a home invasion stabbing told the judge Wednesday that they "firmly" believe their client is innocent.
Bryan Kohberger, a 29-year-old from Pennsylvania, returned to the Latah County courthouse in Moscow, Idaho, for an afternoon hearing on defense efforts for a change of venue that included a controversial survey that prompted the judge to ban both sides from contacting potential jurors.
"Our defense team firmly, and I mean firmly, believes in Mr. Kohberger's innocence, and right now he's being held to have a trial in a county that believes that he is guilty," Elisa Massoth, a Payette-based defense attorney who once attended the same school as the four victims.
IDAHO MURDERS: BRYAN KOHBERGER JUDGE SLAMS DEFENSE QUIZZING LOCALS, SAYS SURVEY ‘CONCERNS’ HIM
Bryan Kohberger enters the courtroom for a hearing at the Latah County Courthouse on June 27, 2023, in Moscow, Idaho. Kohberger is accused of killing four University of Idaho students in November 2022. (August Frank-Pool/Getty Images)
She is a death penalty certified lawyer called in to assist Kohberger, who faces four counts of first-degree murder and a charge of felony burglary in the November 2022 stabbing deaths of Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin in a rental house on the edge of the University of Idaho campus.
Massoth went on to tell the judge that denying a change of venue amounted to denying Kohberger's constitutionally protected right to a fair trial, based on data in the disputed survey.
IDAHO MURDERS SUSPECT BRYAN KOHBERGER WAS UNKNOWN TO VICTIMS, LAWYER SAYS
Madison Mogen, top left, smiles on the shoulders of her best friend, Kaylee Goncalves, as they pose with Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle, and two other housemates in Goncalves' final Instagram post, shared the day before the four students were stabbed to death. (@kayleegoncalves/Instagram)
Two questions in the disputed survey were not part of that public record, he said. One of them, according to the defense expert and survey conductor Bryan Edelman, was about Kohberger stalking at least one of the victims.
It has been widely reported, based on allegations in a probable cause statement unsealed after Kohberger's extradition to Idaho, that he stalked the six-bedroom home on King Road at least a dozen times before the attack and returned one more time about five hours after the murders.
Bill Thompson, the Latah County prosecuting attorney, slammed Taylor's defense strategy and said she appeared to be aimed at tainting the jury pool.
Judge John Judge listens to oral arguments from Bryan Kohberger’s attorney, Jay Logsdon, in court in Moscow, Idaho on Oct. 26, 2023. (Kai Eiselein/Pool)
Edelman, who testified as an expert witness for the defense, said Thompson's critical lens over his work left him "angry" even while conceding he included questions that he knew contained false information.
Massoth pulled statistics from the disputed survey that she claimed show 81% of people who responded had heard about the stalking allegation and "took a position" that Kohberger is "guilty."
She argued that "you can't taint what's tainted," claiming another 79% of the defense's respondents "knew five or more prejudicial and false media reports."
Bryan Kohberger's defense attorneys Anne Taylor, left, Elisa Massoth and Jay Logsdon arrive at the Latah County Courthouse in Moscow, Idaho, on June 27, 2023. (Derek Shook for Fox News Digital)
"These are deeply held opinions in this community, within this jury pool," she said.
Judge John Judge said the "public record" on the case is limited to the case file itself – much of which is sealed – and does not include posts on social media or news reports.
He put a temporary halt on the survey, barring both sides from contacting potential jurors in the case, after the prosecution raised issues about the questions last month. He has not yet decided whether the polling can resume.
Bryan Kohberger arrives at Monroe County Courthouse in Pennsylvania in advance of his extradition hearing. (The Image Direct for Fox News Digital)
Some of the questions read aloud in court include: "Have you read, seen or heard about Bryan Kohberger's arrest at his parents' home in Pennsylvania?," "Have you read, seen or heard if police found a knife sheath on the bed next to one of the victims?" and "Have you read, seen or heard that DNA found on the knife sheath was later matched to Bryan Kohberger?"
Mark Calzaretta, a jury consultant and founding partner at Magna Legal Services, told Fox News Digital that surveys are common practice when the defense is seeking a change of venue.
However, he added, questions are typically tailored to be less specific about particular details in a case and more focused on potential bias itself.
BRYAN KOHBERGER CASE: IDAHO JUDGE BANS BOTH SIDES FROM CONTACTING PROSPECTIVE JURORS
Front view of the house where four Idaho students were killed in November 2022. The house, which was razed in December 2023, was just steps away from the University of Idaho campus. (Adam Sabes/Fox News Digital)
"If I'm trying to elicit bias as a jury consultant, I don't care what their knowledge is about the case, what specific facts they know," he said. "What I want to know is based on what you know, does that tie to the fact that now, just a mere hearing of his name, he's guilty?"
He said if more than 70% to 80% of respondents say yes, the jury pool is "tainted."
However, he said, the defense always has a built-in plan B. If the survey is not enough to convince the judge to grant a change of venue, it will usually still lead to a more rigorous jury selection process.
BRYAN KOHBERGER'S DNA MATCHES SAMPLE FROM KNIFE SHEATH NEAR IDAHO VICTIM MADDIE MOGEN: DA
The victims of the University of Idaho massacre, from left, Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and Madison Mogen. (Instagram @xanakernodle | @maddiemogen | @kayleegoncalves)
Regardless, he said he'd never seen respondents so concerned by a survey before that they reported it to police, as happened in Latah County.
"If they all had that reaction, there's something in that survey that’s maybe over the top," he said. "Then maybe not, and there is a bias, and that’s why they reacted like that."
The court scheduled a number of follow-up hearings and deadlines.
According to the probable cause affidavit, a surviving housemate witnessed a masked intruder leaving from the rear sliding door. (Fox News)
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
The defense is pushing for a change of venue to a larger county with more potential jurors in the jury pool, suggesting Ada, Bonneville and Bannock counties.
Judge will hear arguments on the potential change of venue at 10 a.m. on June 27, and Kohberger's deadline to submit an alibi is next week.
Judge entered not guilty pleas to all of the charges on Kohberger's behalf at his arraignment last year.
Fox News' Sarah Rumpf-Whitten and Audrey Conklin contributed to this report.
True Crime
The hottest stories ripped from the headlines, from crime to courts, legal and scandal.
By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.
