Idaho's move to resurrect firing squad 'makes sense' as 'quickest, surest' death penalty option, expert says
Idaho lawmakers have moved to reinstate the firing squad as a lethal injection alternative for death row inmates
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}As Idaho looks to resurrect the firing squad as an acceptable alternative to lethal injection for prisoners sentenced to death, a shortage of necessary drugs and a poor track record over the past four decades has experts pointing out the shortcomings of the "modern" and "clinical" practice used in most states that still carry out capital punishment.
If signed into law, Idaho's bill could impact the state's eight current death row inmates and possibly the future of student stabbings suspect Bryan Kohberger. He could face death if convicted of any one of four first-degree murder charges he faces in the November deaths of Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin and Xana Kernodle.
"The firing squad is the quickest, surest and most error-free and the only technique for which we have skilled and trained professionals," says Fordham Law School professor Deborah Denno, a leading expert on the death penalty in the U.S.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}Denno, who has studied execution methods for decades, said lethal injection procedures are in a "sorry state" even today, decades after the process became an option in the early 1980s.
IDAHO MURDERS: STATE SENATE PASSES BILL TO REINSTATE EXECUTION BY FIRING SQUAD
Bryan Kohberger, who is accused of killing four University of Idaho students in November, looks at his attorney, public defender Anne Taylor, during a hearing in Latah County District Court in Moscow, Idaho, on Jan. 5, 2023. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, Pool)
"Within the past few years, we've had three people survive lethal injection executions when they were supposed to die," she told Fox News Digital. "And this is after over two hours of people trying to kill them and the state basically saying, 'You've got to stop.'"
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}Executioners have had trouble accessing the veins, drugs are scarce and other things can go wrong.
It happened to Alabama death row inmate Kenneth Eugene Smith in November, the second time in that state alone in as many months.
Kenneth Eugene Smith, who was convicted in a 1988 murder-for-hire slaying of a preacher’s wife, was scheduled to receive a lethal injection at an Alabama prison on Nov. 17, 2022, but officials had to call it off. (Alabama Department of Corrections via AP)
The injection process is also shrouded in secrecy, while firing squads are, by nature, more transparent, with multiple executioners in full view of the witnesses.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}While Denno supports the bill in Idaho, she suggested taking it a step further and, instead of making the firing squad an available alternative when lethal injections cannot be performed, giving death row inmates the choice between the two.
"I have a hunch that more inmates would choose firing squad," she told Fox News Digital, noting that Tennessee inmates have begun choosing electrocution over lethal injection when given the choice.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}The execution, by firing squad, of Maximilian I in 1867. Maximilian I, born Ferdinand Maximilian Joseph, was the only monarch of the Second Mexican Empire. From "The History of our Country," published 1900. (Universal History Archive/Universal Images Group via Getty Images)
"In Tennessee, that's quite a statement, because electrocution has had so many horrible problems associated with it — people's heads burning, their hair burning, eyes popping out, etc.," she said.
The firing squad also meets the Supreme Court's prerequisite as a "known and available alternative," established in the landmark Glossip v. Gross case, she argues.
Denno, who has researched methods of execution for the past three decades, has written seven articles cited by the Supreme Court on the topic, according to her university bio.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}Confessed murderer Margie Velma Barfield in 1984 became the first woman put to death following the reinstatement of the death penalty. She was executed for the poisoning murders of her mother and three others. North Carolina Gov. James Hunt refused to stop the nation's first execution of a woman in 22 years. (Bettmann via Getty Images)
The researcher made clear she is not "pro-death penalty." She's "death penalty agnostic."
"I just think if we're going to be executing people, it should be done in the most humane way possible," she said.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}Only four states have an option for the firing squad, although its use is extremely rare, according to the Death Penalty Information Center, which also in December described lethal injections as the "most-botched" execution method.
Among Mississippi, Oklahoma, Utah and South Carolina, only three prisoners have been put to death by firing squad since 1976.
OKLAHOMA INMATE EXECUTED FOR 1985 SHOOTING DEATH
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}Gary Mark Gilmore was executed by firing squad in Utah in 1977. (Hulton-Deutsch Collection/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty Images)
The first was Gary Mark Gilmore, who, after an 11-year prison sentence for robbery, was released and robbed and killed a gas station clerk and motel manager in 1976. Six months later, after a hunger strike and failed appeal, he died by firing squad.
Next was John Albert Taylor, who raped and strangled an 11-year-old girl in 1989. He chose a firing squad over lethal injection because he was worried about "flipping around like a fish out of water," The Associated Press reported at the time.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}The chair in which John Albert Taylor was strapped during his scheduled execution is shown at Unitas State Prison in Utah on Jan. 24, 1996. Taylor chose to die by a firing squad of five men instead of a lethal injection. (Lee Celano/Reuters)
Then came Ronnie Lee Gardner in 2010. While in court for a bartender's death, he killed a lawyer and shot a bailiff in a failed attempt to escape custody.
"That was last execution by firing squad in the U.S.," said Matt Mangino, a former Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, district attorney who also previously sat on the state's parole board.
He now works in private practice and wrote a book on the issue, "The Executioner's Toll, 2010."
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}South Carolina's renovated Capital Punishment Facility, with the firing squad chair at left behind the covered electric chair, is seen from the witness room at Broad River Correctional Institution in Columbia, S.C., in an undated photograph. (South Carolina Department of Corrections/Handout via REUTERS)
"Most states that had the firing squad moved away from that form of execution because of the ‘Wild West’ mentality it portrayed," Mangino told Fox News Digital. "Some say lethal injection is clinical or sanitary, the firing squad is 'uncivilized.'"
But injections can be gruesome too, experts say. And while there is less visible blood, Mangino noted that one drug in the common three-drug cocktail is a paralytic meant to keep the condemned still for witnesses' comfort, not to ease the pain of death.
"It's unsightly and uncomfortable for witnesses to see someone gyrating and moving around as they’re going through the throes of death during lethal injection," Mangino said.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}A bill to reinstate the firing squad passed the Idaho House and Senate with a veto-proof majority and was sent Gov. Brad Little's desk. (Brian Losness/Handout via REUTERS)
Idaho's bill passed with a veto-proof majority, but it was not without opposition.
"This is an important bill for victims, their families and the rule of law," the bill's House sponsor, Rep. Bruce Skaug, R-Nampa, told Fox News Digital this week.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}An executioner's view through the canvas screen that shielded the firing squad from Gary Gilmore. Five riflemen fired four bullets through the slits in the screen at Gilmore, who sat in the chair viewed through the screen. (Bettmann via Getty Images)
The bill passed the state House 50-15-5 earlier this month and the Senate 24-11 on Monday before it was sent to Gov. Brad Little's desk.
"Upon signature of the governor, the state may now more likely carry out justice, as determined by our judicial system, against those who have committed first-degree murder," Skaug said.
State Sen. Dan Foreman, R-Moscow, argued that the people assigned to the firing squad, the witnesses and the cleanup crew are all at risk of becoming traumatized by the experience, according to The Associated Press.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}However, Mangino noted, ahead of Gardner's 2010 execution, hundreds of people volunteered to be part of the firing squad.
The execution chamber at the Idaho Maximum Security Institution is shown as Security Institution Warden Randy Blades looks on in Boise, Idaho, on Oct. 20, 2011. (AP Photo/Jessie L. Bonner, File)
"I don’t think people who are in law enforcement are worried about PTSD from being on a firing squad," he said.
And as states struggle to obtain lethal injection drugs, there is no shortage of people willing to serve on a firing squad or of guns to carry out the penalty.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}Madison Mogen smiles on the shoulders of her best friend, Kaylee Goncalves, as they pose with Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and two other housemates in Goncalves' final Instagram post, shared the day before the four students were stabbed to death. (@kayleegoncalves/Instagram)
Still, Edwina Elcox, a Boise-based defense attorney, earlier this week called the concept of using a firing squad "atrocious."
"Execution by way of firing squad is antiquated and, bottom line, inhumane," she told Fox News Digital on Tuesday. "It is deeply concerning that Idaho is reverting to such barbaric methods."
But compared to the Old West's favored method — hanging — and stacked up against lethal injections, the electric chair and other modern procedures, the firing squad is the most humane and the least prone to error, Denno argued.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}STUDIES: DEATH PENALTY DISCOURAGES CRIME
Reporters Scott McGrew and Amy Donaldson view the cell where John Albert Taylor spent his final day before his firing squad execution at the Unita State Penitentiary in Utah in 1996. (Reuters/POOL)
In addition to a persistent scarcity of approved lethal injection drugs, the procedure is also difficult for a number of reasons, Denno said.
Condemned inmates often have vein damage due to prolonged drug use, some of them are too obese and others have too much muscle, she said. Others are so nervous their veins contract.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
In some gruesome cases, executioners are forced to cut into the inmate's neck or groin to find a place to insert the needle. At times, condemned inmates have even assisted prison personnel in inserting it themselves.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.