Former NYPD inspector breaks down Gilgo Beach evidence
Fox News contributor Paul Mauro joins 'America's Newsroom' to discuss the evidence against Gilgo Beach murder suspect Rex Heuermann as he is reportedly expected to face a fourth count.
RIVERHEAD, N.Y. – Rex Heuermann, the suspected Gilgo Beach serial killer accused of dumping his victims in the brush alongside Ocean Parkway east of New York City, has been charged with a fourth murder.
Heuermann already faces six charges total in the deaths of Melissa Barthelemy, 24, Megan Waterman, 22, and Amber Costello, 27. Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney called him the prime suspect in the death of the fourth victim, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25, when he announced the first set of charges last year.
A superseding indictment handed down Tuesday charges Heuermann with the second-degree murder of Brainard-Barnes.
Rex Heuermann enters Timothy P. Mazzei’s courtroom with his attorney Michael Brown. (James Carbone / Newsday via Pool)
Heuermann entered the courtroom Tuesday morning in a dark suit. His attorney, Michael Brown, entered a not guilty plea and reserved the right to make a bail application. Heuermann was remanded without bail on the new indictment and is due back in court on Feb. 16. The entire hearing took about a minute after attorney from both sides met behind closed doors with the judge.
‘HAPPY FACE’ SERIAL KILLER BRAGS HE'S PEN PALS WITH GILGO BEACH SUSPECT REX HEUERMANN
Rex Heuermann listens to his attorney Michael Brown. (James Carbone / Newsday via Pool)
Speaking to reporters afterward, Brown disputed the DNA evidence in the case, saying this is the first mention of nuclear DNA and that he believes the mitochondrial DNA does not show a match with enough specificity. He said statistically there could be 600 matches in Nassau and Suffolk counties.
He suggested that Costello's pimp, who had described Heuermann as an ogre and gave the description of the Chevy Avalanche that investigators have linked to Heuermann, is a drug user and not credible.
Read the latest court filings in Rex Heuermann's Gilgo Beach case
Asa Ellerup, Heuermann's estranged wife, attended his court appearance Tuesday. Her attorney, Bob Macedonio, said afterward that it was a "horrible day" but that the new indictment "again makes clear that Asa Ellerup and her children were not involved, [or] even in the jurisdiction, when these murders took place," he told reporters.
The new filing states that Ellerup and the couple's children were away in Atlantic City at the time of Brainard-Barnes' murder.
Asa Ellerup, daughter Victoria Heuermann and son Christopher Sheridan walk thorugh a parking lot in Atlantic City, New Jersey, July 18, 2023. (Dario Alequin for Fox News Digital )
Heuermann's arrest on July 13, 2023, "was a surprise to Asa Ellerup and her children," Macedonio added. "This life that existed, or may have existed, they were completely unaware of."
LISTEN TO 'GRIM TIDE: HUNTING THE LONG ISLAND SERIAL KILLER' ON FOX NEWS RADIO
Tierney told reporters after the hearing that investigators charged Heuermann with Brainard-Barnes' death months after the other victims because they were waiting for the results of "cutting-edge" SNP process testing, which he said came back an overwhelming match in the case.
Investigators found Brainard-Barnes bound with three leather belts – one of them around her ankles. Hair on that one showed a genetic link to Ellerup, according to the new filing. Waterman's remains were bound in duct tape, according to prosecutors, and a hair recovered from her binding's also matched Ellerup. A male hair in the burlap material used to conceal her remains allegedly matched Heuermann directly, according to court filings.
Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney, left, inside Judge Timothy P. Mazzei’s courtroom at Suffolk County Court in Riverhead on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024, where alleged Gilgo Killer Rex Heuermann, far right, was arraigned in the death of Maureen Brainard-Barnes. Heuermann is standing next to defense attorney Michael Brown. (James Carbone / Newsday via Pool)
Tierney previously indicated that the hair evidence was likely transferred to the victims by Heuermann inadvertently and said his wife had been out of town during each of the murders.
Costello, who was bound with tape and a burlap material, also had transferred hair, according to the superseding indictment – this time Victoria Heuermann, the suspect's daughter, who was 13 at the time of the slaying and away with her mother.
Brainard-Barnes' daughter and younger sister delivered emotional statements alongside their attorney Gloria Allred after the proceedings.
"I want her to be remembered as the loving mother who she was," her daughter, Nicolette Brainard-Barnes, said. She was 7 at the time of the slaying.
Nicolette Brainard-Barnes holds a photo of herself with her mother, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, during a press conference after suspected Long Island serial killer Rex Heuermann appeared in court today to face an additional murder charge for the death of Brainard-Barnes. (Robert Miller for Fox News Digital)
Melissa Cann, Brainard-Barnes' younger sister, urged the public to remember all of the Gilgo victims, not just the four whose cases have resulted in charges so far.
Heuermann led a quiet life in a New York suburb for decades with a wife and two kids, one of whom grew up to work with him at his Manhattan architectural firm.
Neighbors knew him as a local businessman who walked to the train in a suit and carried a briefcase, sometimes stopping at the local bars after work and doing a shoddy job keeping up the maintenance on his house, which has cedar shake shingles with peeling paint in a neighborhood where everyone else has since upgraded to vinyl siding.
Rex Heuermann’s house in Massapequa Park. (MEGA for Fox News Digital )
Then, in July, prosecutors in neighboring Suffolk County identified him as the prime suspect in a cold case serial killer investigation that has mystified area residents and true crime followers since 2010 – the Gilgo Beach murders.
SUSPECTED GILGO BEACH SERIAL KILLER REX HEUERMANN TAKEN OFF JAIL'S SUICIDE WATCH, SHERIFF SAYS
Heuermann stands 6-feet, 4-inches tall and has been described by former Suffolk County Police Commissioner Rodney Harrison as both a "demon" and an "ogre." Despite his quiet demeanor, police allege he brutally killed the women and hid their bodies in camouflage burlap material.
Tierney announced charges against Heuermann Tuesday for the fourth of the "Gilgo Four" victims – a group of women found dumped close to one another off Ocean Parkway about 45 miles east of New York City.
Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney speaks to the media during a press conference following the hearing. (Robert Miller for Fox News Digital)
He had been charged with the other three in 2023, more than a decade after the first bodies were found.
The case unfolded after police received a haunting 911 call from Shannan Gilbert in 2010 and began searching for her near Oak Beach, a few miles to the east.
Crews looked through the dense brush north of Ocean Parkway for months, uncovering the Gilgo Four and a half-dozen other bodies before they finally found Gilbert's remains.
Police Cadets Search the Beaches and Thick Brush on the Side of the Road Near Oak Beach in April, 2011. (Andrew Gombert/EPA/Shutterstock)
Years later, police said that they believed Gilbert's death was not a homicide. Officially, it has been deemed undetermined, but Suffolk County Police Lt. Kevin Beyrer told reporters in May 2022 that other evidence suggested she had died by accident.
The other deaths remain under investigation by a grand jury, Tierney said Tuesday.
"With regard to those other bodies and those other murders, the task force will continue to investigate those cases," he added.
"Gilgo Four" victim Melissa Barthelemy, who was last seen on July 12, 2009 – almost 14 years to the day before police would arrest her suspected killer, Rex Heuermann, a Long Island architect and father of two who they now allege is the Gilgo Beach serial killer. (Suffolk County Police)
Brainard-Barnes was last seen on July 9, 2007; Barthelemy on July 10, 2009, Waterman on Jun 6, 2010, and Costello on Sept. 2, 2010.
A police officer named John Malia was running a K-9 training exercise near Gilgo Beach on Dec. 11, 2010, when his dog Blue led him to Barthelemy's remains. Two days later, Suffolk County police recovered Brainard-Barnes, Waterman and Costello, and autopsies identified the cause of death for all four as "homicidal violence."
Each had been dumped between 22 and 33 feet from the edge of the road, according to investigators. Ocean Parkway runs east and west along the Atlantic Ocean outside New York City. Despite the proximity, there are few homes and businesses along the route.
Maureen Brainard-Barnes was 25 years old when she was last seen alive in July 2007. She was reported missing on July 14, 2007. (Suffolk County Police Department)
WATCH: ‘GRIM TIDE’ ON FOX NATION
According to court documents, all four victims shared several things in common – they were sex workers, they were missing clothing and "personal possessions," and all had been in contact with someone using a "burner" phone.
They were all positioned the same way, had been bound in similar fashion – and three were wrapped in the camo burlap material used to make duck blinds, according to authorities.
The locations where eight of 10 bodies were found near Gilgo Beach since December 2010 are seen in this Suffolk County Police handout image. (Reuters/Courtesy of Suffolk County Police)
Additionally, all four were "petite." Barthelemy, Costello and Brainard-Barnes were all less than 5-feet tall, according to Suffolk County police. Waterman's height is not listed with the others on the department's Gilgo news website.
GO HERE FOR MORE TRUE CRIME FROM FOX NEWS DIGITAL
In Brainard-Barnes' and Barthelemy's cases, the victims' phones had been used to repeatedly taunt their families after the murders, prosecutors allege.
Amber Lynn Costello was 27 when she was last seen alive on Sept. 2, 2010, although her roommates never reported her missing. Suffolk police found her remains on Dec. 13, 2010, during a search for missing Shannan Gilbert. (Suffolk County Police Department)
GILGO BEACH SUSPECT REX HEUERMANN STALKED EX-COP AFTER TRAIN ALTERCATION, RIDER SAYS
The investigation, however, languished for years – before Tierney and Harrison announced a new task force dedicated to crack the cold case.
Six weeks later, the Gilgo Beach investigators found their first major break, Tierney said. A witness in Costello's disappearance had identified a "first-generation" Chevrolet Avalanche pickup truck as the suspect vehicle – and authorities discovered one fitting the description had been registered to Heuermann.
Megan Waterman was 22 years old when she vanished on June 6, 2010, on security video from a Holiday Inn Express hotel in Hauppauge, New York. Suffolk County police found her remains on Dec. 13, 2010, near Gilgo Beach during the search for Shannan Gilbert. (Suffolk County Police Department)
Additionally, advances in mitochondrial DNA testing technology also allowed investigators to link existing hair samples to the suspect's household.
GILGO BEACH MURDERS: THE INVESTIGATION IN PHOTOS
Three hundred subpoenas and search warrants later, investigators were looking at him as their prime suspect.
Hair samples taken from tape used to bind the victims matched his wife's DNA, according to prosecutors, although she is not a suspect.
Rex Heuermann's wife, Asa Ellerup and daughter Victoria Heuermann depart the Suffolk County Courthouse after the hearing. (Robert Miller for Fox News Digital)
"During the commission of those murders, the defendant's wife and children were out of New York state, and he was alone in the tri-state area," Tierney said during Friday's news briefing. Investigators believe the hair was transferred to the victims from the tape, burlap or other items Heuermann allegedly used in the crimes.
Further DNA testing found Heuermann's own hair in the camouflage burlap found on Waterman, according to court filings. It also matched DNA found in a pizza box police allegedly watched him toss in a New York City trash can in January.
The discarded pizza box and the bin where it was thrown away. The pizza crust was used to collect DNA allegedly linking Rex Heuermann to one of the dead bodies. (Suffolk County DA)
At the same time, investigators found consistent links between the phone records of Heuermann, his alleged "burner" phones and the victims.
"For each of the murders, he got an individual burner phone, and he used that to communicate with the victims," Tierney said. "Then, shortly after the death of the victims, he then would get rid of the burner phone."
POLICE SEEN SWARMING BASEMENT AT ARCHITECT'S RAMSHACKLE HOME IN GILGO BEACH SERIAL KILLER PROBE
He had a new "burner" phone with him in Manhattan when police arrested him Thursday, authorities said – which shared a connection to an email account he'd used in the past.
A road sign directing drivers to Gilgo Beach off Ocean Parkway, about 45 miles east of New York City. (Michael Ruiz/Fox News Digital)
They even found about 200 Google search records showing he was closely following news about the Gilgo investigation, as well as podcasts and documentaries.
SUSPECTED LONG ISLAND SERIAL KILLER'S DUCK HUNTING COULD HAVE BEEN PERFECT COVER FOR HIDING BODIES
He was watching the investigators, Tierney said, so the task force kept its work under a tight lid.
"He was searching, compulsively searching pictures of the victims, but not only pictures of the victims, pictures of their relatives, their sisters, their children, and he was trying to locate those individuals," Tierney said.
When Heuermann was not looking for updates on the Gilgo case, he was searching for gruesome and illicit pornography, prosecutors alleged, and he allegedly continued to "patronize sex workers" until shortly before his arrest," Tierney said previously.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Heuermann was born and raised in Massapequa Park, New York. He bought his childhood home from his mother in the 1990s and moved his own family there. Neighbors described him as quiet and unassuming, but some said they got creepy vibes from the unkempt home, which has aging siding, twisted flashing along the roof and two-by-four lumber holding up the front awning.
Stay with Fox News Digital all day for updates and analysis on today's indictment.
True Crime
The hottest stories ripped from the headlines, from crime to courts, legal and scandal.
By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.
