Kavanaugh in fiery exchange with Sen. Durbin over call for FBI probe

close

Video

Durbin challenges Kavanaugh to call for FBI investigation

Senator Durbin tells Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh to ask White House counsel Don McGahn to urge President Trump to suspend the nomination process until an FBI investigation is completed.

Supreme Court nominee Judge Brett Kavanaugh engaged in a fiery exchange with Democratic Sen. Dick Durbin over calls for an FBI investigation into the sexual misconduct allegations leveled against him by three women.

Durbin, as part of his questioning of Kavanaugh Thursday, challenged the Supreme Court nominee to himself request an FBI investigation of the allegations.

“I’ve got a suggestion for you. Right now, turn to your left, in the front row, to [White House Counsel] Don McGahn,” Durbin said. “Ask him to suspend this hearing and nomination process until the FBI completes its investigation of the charges made by Dr. Ford and others.”

Kavanaugh said in his opening statement that he was open to “any kind of investigation.”

“Senate, FBI, or otherwise. The committee has now conducted a thorough investigation,” Kavanaugh said in his opening statement. “I know any kind of investigation—Senate, FBI, Montgomery County Police—will clear me.”

In response to Durbin’s suggestion, though, Kavanaugh said: “I will do whatever the committee wants to do because I’m telling the truth,” maintaining, however, that the FBI does not reach conclusions.

“I’m innocent of this charge,” Kavanaugh said, adding that the committee is responsible for coming to conclusions of the investigation.

Durbin fired back, challenging Kavanaugh.

“If there is no truth to her charges, the FBI investigation will show that,” Durbin said.

Kavanaugh responded that he was “telling the truth.”

Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, interrupted the exchange, and said they were not going to do anything to interrupt the hearing.

Later, Grassley tried to set the record straight regarding FBI background investigations.

“Any senator who’s brought up this issue could have asked for an investigation. The FBI gathers information for the White House, which is sent to the committee,” Grassley said, adding that the FBI found that there was “no federal crime alleged to investigate.”

“If Senate Democrats want the FBI to draw conclusions, I’m going to remind you what Joe Biden said,” Grassley added. Grassley quoted former Vice President Joe Biden during Christine Blasey Ford’s testimony earlier Thursday.

During the confirmation proceedings for Justice Clarence Thomas, and Anita Hill's testimony, Biden chaired the Senate Judiciary Committee.

“The next person who refers to an FBI report as being worth anything obviously doesn’t understand anything. The FBI explicitly does not in this or any other case reach a conclusion. Period,” Grassley read. “They say he said, she said, and they said, period. So when people wave an FBI report before you, understand they do not, they do not, they do not reach conclusions. They do not make recommendations.”

A spokesman for Biden blasted Republicans for taking Biden’s comments “out of context.”

"There is clearly an effort on the part of the White House and Senate Republicans to take out of context then-Senator Biden's statements about the role of the FBI in the judicial nomination process to create a smoke-screen for their unprecedented refusal to have the FBI conduct an investigation into credible charges,” the spokesman said.

"Senator Biden made those comments in response to Senator Hatch's attempts to frame the FBI's 1991 report on Clarence Thomas as exculpatory. His point was that the FBI plays an investigative role in the nomination process; they do not make recommendations," Biden's spokesman said. "That is the sole responsibility of the Senate -- to advise and consent.  Vice President Biden believes that the FBI should have investigated this case in advance of Dr. Blasey Ford's courageous testimony today, just as they did in 1991."

Ford, Deborah Ramirez, and Julie Swetnick—the women accusing Kavanaugh of sexual misconduct—have all called for an FBI investigation.

In a statement released by the White House late Thursday, in an effort to “set the record straight” on the FBI process, they noted that it is “the job of the Senate to assess and investigate a nominee’s qualifications when deciding whether to consent a nomination.”

“The Committee’s standard procedure for supplemental background investigations is to conduct phone or in-person interviews with the relevant parties to discuss the underlying issues,” the White House statement read. “In this case, an FBI investigation would not involve an investigation into the facts surrounding a 36-year-old party.”

The statement added: “That would be outside the FBI’s regular jurisdiction. Instead, the FBI would obtain statements from the alleged participants and pass along those statements to the White House and the Senate Judiciary Committee.”

Alleged participants, according to the White House, have provided statements on the matter to the Committee, which Grassley acknowledged Thursday, listing the names of those Ford claimed were at the gathering where the alleged sexual assault occurred.

“The FBI would not make a determination of the credibility of these allegations, or of Judge Kavanaugh’s guilt or innocence in this matter,” the White House said.

Fox News' Mike Emanuel contributed to this report.